Mathewson, Christy

Christy Mathewson Baseball Cards

Q: How do I know these cards are authentic?

Every card we sell is guaranteed 100% authentic. With over 40 years of experience, we personally inspect all inventory—both raw and graded—to ensure our customers receive only genuine collectibles.

Here you find baseball cards of Christy Mathewson.

To learn more about Christy Mathewson, visit the link below:

Christy Mathewson's Info Page

Display

1961 Topps #408 Christy Mathewson
1961 Topps #408 Christy Mathewson
This is a 1961 Topps Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #408. Please see image to assess condition.
$15.99 $12.79
Stock Level 1
This is a 1961 Topps Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #408. Please see image to assess condition.
1996 Collectors Choice #503 Christy Mathewson First Class
1996 Collectors Choice #503 Christy...
This is a 1996 Collector's Choice Christy Mathewson First Class baseball card. The card is #503 and is in NM-MT conditi…
$0.50 $0.40
Stock Level 1
This is a 1996 Collector's Choice Christy Mathewson First Class baseball card. The card is #503 and is in NM-MT conditi…
2006 Upper Deck All-Time Legends #ATL-8 Christy Mathewson
2006 Upper Deck All-Time Legends...
This is a 2006 Upper Deck All-Time Legends Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #ATL-8 and is in NM-MT conditio…
$2.49 $1.99
Stock Level 1
This is a 2006 Upper Deck All-Time Legends Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #ATL-8 and is in NM-MT conditio…
2006 Upper Deck First Class Legends #FCL-69 Christy Mathewson
2006 Upper Deck First Class Legends...
This is a 2006 Upper Deck First Class Legends Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #FCL-69 and is in NM-MT cond…
$1.25 $1.00
Stock Level 1
This is a 2006 Upper Deck First Class Legends Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #FCL-69 and is in NM-MT cond…
2006 Upper Deck First Class Legends #FCL-75 Christy Mathewson
2006 Upper Deck First Class Legends...
This is a 2006 Upper Deck First Class Legends Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #FCL-75 and is in NM-MT cond…
$1.25 $1.00
Stock Level 1
This is a 2006 Upper Deck First Class Legends Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #FCL-75 and is in NM-MT cond…
2009 Topps Legends of the Game #LG3 Christy Mathewson
2009 Topps Legends of the Game #LG3...
This is a 2009 Topps Legends of the Game Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #LG3 and is in NM-MT condition.
$2.00 $1.60
Stock Level 1
This is a 2009 Topps Legends of the Game Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #LG3 and is in NM-MT condition.
2009 Topps Triple Threads #54 Christy Mathewson
2009 Topps Triple Threads #54...
This is a 2009 Topps Triple Threads Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #54 and is in NM-MT condition.This car…
$2.49 $1.99
Stock Level 2
This is a 2009 Topps Triple Threads Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #54 and is in NM-MT condition.This car…
2010 Topps History of the World Series #HWS1 Christy Mathewson
2010 Topps History of the World...
This is a 2010 Topps History of the World Series Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #HWS1 and is in NM-MT con…
$2.00 $1.60
Stock Level 1
This is a 2010 Topps History of the World Series Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #HWS1 and is in NM-MT con…
2010 Topps Logoman #HTA-46 Christy Mathewson
2010 Topps Logoman #HTA-46 Christy...
This is a 2010 Topps Logoman Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #HTA-46 and is in NM-MT condition.
$1.50 $1.20
Stock Level 1
This is a 2010 Topps Logoman Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #HTA-46 and is in NM-MT condition.
2010 Topps Vintage Legends Collection #VLC11 Christy Mathewson
2010 Topps Vintage Legends...
This is a 2010 Topps Vintage Legends Collection Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #VLC11 and is in NM-MT con…
$2.00 $1.60
Stock Level 1
This is a 2010 Topps Vintage Legends Collection Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #VLC11 and is in NM-MT con…
2011 Topps 60 #T60-131 Christy Mathewson
2011 Topps 60 #T60-131 Christy...
This is a 2011 Topps 60 Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #T60-131 and is in NM-MT condition.
$2.00 $1.60
Stock Level 1
This is a 2011 Topps 60 Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #T60-131 and is in NM-MT condition.
2011 Topps CMG Reprints #CMGR-6 Christy Mathewson 1911 T205
2011 Topps CMG Reprints #CMGR-6...
This is a 2011 Topps CMG Reprints Christy Mathewson 1911 T206 baseball card. The card is #CMGR-6 and is in NM-MT condit…
$2.00 $1.60
Stock Level 2
This is a 2011 Topps CMG Reprints Christy Mathewson 1911 T206 baseball card. The card is #CMGR-6 and is in NM-MT condit…
2011 Topps Cognac Diamond Anniversary #102 Christy Mathewson
2011 Topps Cognac Diamond...
This is a 2011 Topps Cognac Diamond Anniversary Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #102 and is in NM-MT condi…
$7.99 $6.39
Stock Level 1
This is a 2011 Topps Cognac Diamond Anniversary Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #102 and is in NM-MT condi…
2011 Topps Kimball Champions #KC-122 Christy Mathewson
2011 Topps Kimball Champions...
This is a 2011 Topps Kimball Champions Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #KC-122 and is in NM-MT condition.
$1.50 $1.20
Stock Level 1
This is a 2011 Topps Kimball Champions Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #KC-122 and is in NM-MT condition.
2019 Stadium Club #29 Christy Mathewson
2019 Stadium Club #29 Christy...
This is a 2019 Stadium Club Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #29 and is in NM-MT condition.
$0.75 $0.60
Stock Level 1
This is a 2019 Stadium Club Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #29 and is in NM-MT condition.
2019 Topps 150 Years of Professional Baseball Greatest Moments #GM-2 Christy Mathewson
2019 Topps 150 Years of...
This is a 2019 Topps 150 Years of Professional Baseball Greatest Moments Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #G…
$1.00 $0.80
Stock Level 1
This is a 2019 Topps 150 Years of Professional Baseball Greatest Moments Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #G…
2021 Diamond Kings #16 Christy Mathewson
2021 Diamond Kings #16 Christy...
This is a 2021 Diamond Kings Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #16 and is in NM-MT condition.
$0.75 $0.60
Stock Level 4
This is a 2021 Diamond Kings Christy Mathewson baseball card. The card is #16 and is in NM-MT condition.

Collector FAQs: Christy Mathewson Baseball Cards

Are Christy Mathewson Baseball Cards a good investment?

Generally, Christy Mathewson Baseball Cards are considered strong investments, especially rookie cards and low-population graded examples.

How do I know these cards are authentic?

We take authenticity seriously. With over 40 years of experience in the hobby, every card in our inventory is guaranteed 100% authentic. Whether a card is professionally graded or a "raw" ungraded card, we personally inspect every item to ensure it is genuine before it ever hits our shelves.